Tools and the Preacher: Using AI with Wisdom and Discernment
My wife recently shared a clip she saw: Jerry Seinfeld joked about artificial intelligence, saying, “So, we are smart enough to create AI, and we’re dumb enough to need it.”1 Seinfeld’s wit is sharp, and the line got a laugh, but it misses the mark. Tools—whether ancient or cutting-edge—don’t emerge from human stupidity but from God-given creativity and intelligence.
Tools Reflect Our Creativity
Humans create tools because we are made in the image of a creative God. Tools amplify our abilities, enabling us to focus on higher-level tasks. From hammers to calculators, tools embody our ingenuity and allow us to achieve things that would otherwise be impossible or inefficient.
To dismiss tools as a sign of weakness overlooks the deeper truth: tool-making is central to what it means to be human.
Amplifying Human Capability
Take the hammer. A hammer doesn’t build a house; it amplifies the strength and skill of the carpenter wielding it. The carpenter still brings the design, expertise, and effort, but the hammer enables him to accomplish the work more efficiently and effectively. Without it, the same task would take longer, demand more energy, and likely yield poorer results.
Similarly, consider calculators. Before their invention, complex mathematical operations required significant training and time. Calculators didn’t make humans worse at math; they freed mathematicians to focus on solving higher-order problems. Tools like these take repetitive, labor-intensive tasks and make them quicker, more accurate, and more efficient—unlocking creativity and innovation.
Artificial intelligence functions much the same way. At its best, AI is a tool that helps us focus on tasks only humans can do—creative thought, moral decision-making, and building relationships. Just as a carpenter isn’t diminished by using a hammer, or a mathematician by using a calculator, we shouldn’t feel diminished by using AI thoughtfully.
Tools as a Hallmark of Humanity
The invention of tools isn’t a sign of dependence or laziness; it reflects human ingenuity. From the beginning, we’ve been problem-solvers and creators, shaping the world with everything from sharpened stones to advanced AI. Tools reveal our desire to overcome limitations and extend our God-given abilities.
In a theological sense, tools highlight our role in God’s creation. We are unique among creatures, made to subdue and steward the earth (Genesis 1:28). This mandate requires creativity and resourcefulness, and tools help fulfill that calling. The invention of AI isn’t a departure from this tradition—it’s the latest chapter in humanity’s long history of using intelligence to solve problems.
AI: Another Tool in the Toolbox
When we see AI as a tool, we put it in its proper place. Like a hammer or a calculator, AI doesn’t replace human effort or intelligence—it extends and enhances it. Preachers can view AI not as a competitor but as a servant. AI won’t do your job for you, but it can help you do your job better.
AI tools, like commentaries and Bible software, can be used responsibly. Let me explain how I approach it.
Practical Uses for AI in Ministry
I regularly use AI for a variety of tasks. ChatGPT has helped me create weight-lifting routines, pantry-cleaning recipes, podcast outlines, Bible-reading plans, and much more. It’s also a helpful tool in my sermon preparation—not to write sermons, but to support my study.
Here are two ways I use AI for sermon work:
High-Powered Search Engine
AI functions like an advanced concordance. It quickly cross-references related passages in Scripture, the PCA Book of Church Order, or the Westminster Standards.
Example: When my wife recently asked about a theme in Proverbs, I recommended a concordance but then realized ChatGPT could search faster.
Caution: AI may lack theological nuance, so always verify its suggestions with trusted sources.
Research and Proofreading Assistant
Tools like Notebook LM allow me to upload resources like the Westminster Standards or commentary chapters, creating a custom database for focused research.
Example: I can ask how the Westminster Standards address Christian liberty or compare how different commentators interpret a specific term.
Caution: Even within a closed database, AI may miss subtle distinctions, especially in theological texts. Always double-check.
Caution!
Even with my examples of careful use, I really can’t express how cautious you need to be. Here are some matters to be aware of, in no particular order:
Get Your Prompts Right: Learning to craft effective queries is a skill. Experiment with rephrasing if responses lack depth.
Only Use It If You’re an Expert: AI should supplement—not replace—rigorous study, prayer, and reflection. Test all output against trusted commentaries and Scripture.
Nothing Replaces Meditation and Thoughtfulness. Do not use AI as a tool to skip the necessary parts of sermon prep. If this is a temptation for you, don’t use AI at all.
Don’t Let AI Generate Your Content: AI-generated material can be generic and impersonal and plagiaristic. Sermons should arise from your personal study and pastoral care.
Avoid Dependency: Over-reliance on AI may hinder your growth in Scripture study and theology. Prioritize time in God’s Word and trusted resources.
Maintain Congregational Trust: Misusing AI could damage your credibility and the authenticity of your ministry.
The Role of AI in Ministry
Used wisely, AI can save time, provide new insights, and organize complex information. However, it must be wielded with discernment, humility, and a commitment to Scripture. Remember: no tool—AI included—can replace the Holy Spirit’s power working through a pastor faithfully preaching God’s Word. Let tools like AI serve you, but never let them substitute for your calling as a preacher of the gospel.